Echo's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Piano_Force [Box Killa]]

Not a bad job...

left me wishing for more, so that's great, but it could use something else. I knwo its meant to be only piano but maybe heavier chords in the background could help ur cause.

Its still a good piece IMO but it could use more though, There were virtually no build ups too the end. The outro was abrupt but the intro set off great.

Overall, it deserves to get fours and eights but no more for now. If u make thsi better, u'll be getting tens in no time.

Darklight17
-Review Request Club-

[Icewalkers ( Naked )]

Quite simple, but sounds good...

U could've made it a hell of a lot more complicated, from where i stand (and listen) i see a great deal of potential for this.

U definetely managed to harmonize the treble and bass quite well, although some parts were slightly off.

The intro was way too simple and needs more of a build up.

What would really bring this through would be a stronger background, there are too few instruments, strings, drums and maybe even a bass guitar woudl definetely help to make this better,

Overall, its a good piece, there were pretty decent buildups but it needs some more work.

Darklight17
-Review Request Club-

Sawdust responds:

Thanks a lot!

[SN |Lost, But on Her Way| SN]

The Afterlife...

Well, u definetely started of well, that voice really set it off brilliantly, however, it didn't continue brilliantly. I don't particularly like the stuttering beats and melodie towards the middle, they break up the smooth flow of the song.

On the other hand, u definetely portrayed the spirit world well so i gav u a couple of point for that. The outro, although slightly abrupt, was great. IMO it seemed as if there was more to come which is great for any album song,

Overall, a well thought out piece, great work!

Darklight17
-Review Request Club-

SessileNomad responds:

the stutters are really a genre thing, and compared to some of the more "hardcore" idm stuff, this is actually qutie light

thanks for the review, glad you like it

[open sound]

Quoting Coop "Simple and...weird"

yes, its definetely different. One sound melodies don't normally become so popular. The melody u used is also quite simple and it didn't have that much of a varied feel to it

However, this would work really well as a background instrument so all u need is a few drums, several more isntruments a few lessons in harmony and voila. U got urself a piece of good music.

Overall, its a good piece but it definetely needs more work.

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

mikkim responds:

This was not supposed to have anything else than the one sound.

[Waaaar!]

Waaaar??????

That is insanely a strange name. Although its just an opinion there. Maybe you could think of a more...how shall i put this...descriptive name? U could also use some imagination on that part, i mean honestly, waaaar isn't even a word!

Anyway, on to actually reviewing the music. Well its definetely heavy metal so i guess u captured the style brilliantly. U used good samples although they had a bit too much distortion in them which ruined some of the parts of the song.

However, despite the distortion, the piece is intricately varied and the differing melodies make it interesting. Transitions were smooth and well thought out.

Not a bad job, u definetely need some more work though.

Darkligth17
=Review Request Club=

Centrist responds:

There are only so many words out there that you can place as a song name, and half of those are taken by other useres. :p So, why not invent your own?

In any case, thank you for the review. I didn't spend a whole lot of time on this track, but I'm glad you like it. :]

[Intercontinental]

Pretty decent job...

Intro was a bit strange and off chord in some parts but the build up to the main melody was great. although the background got a bit repetitve in some parts.

Transitions were smooth overall but there were some skips in certain parts. However, u did a very good job on this, and with a little more work, u'll be getting tens and a lot of them.

Good job! Keep it up!

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

[PureX (Final State)]

Not exactly dance...

It isn't much of a dance tune cos there isn't a consistent beat throughout, if u know what i mean. maybe u need to change the genre.

Still, its great and well thought out. You definetely put in a lot of work into this and it shows. The calm melody seems to be hiding something shadowy and energetic which then jsut bursts out. Great work.

Overall, its a great piece of music and it deserves the nine i gave it.

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

DavidRx responds:

i shud totaly change the genre but i have a prob to do thut...cud U or SOME1 tell me whut to put it on?
=D

thx man yea totaly took me a great deal of time...doing it...still i aint done...i want to improve it in so many ways...cuz as long as i do it i am learning even more :)

build ups,
the power of EQ,
reverb FX and so on...
i just need to know or have some one give me tips n crtics like you guys...
thx a lot =D

DrX

[(CHS) Death Match!!!]

Good work.

It has a very lets-go-ahead-and-kill-something feel to it (no idea if that's really a feeling but...)

It definetely portrays a battle well, the fast pacem interesting melodies, rhytmic drumbeats, great background and smooth transtitions make this song fantastic. Keep it up and i can't wait to hear the next one.

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

ChaosDragon004 responds:

Hey thanks alot bro. That means alot. Well I hope to give you something worth coming back for! I did enjoy making this peace.

[Halloween (Brutal Mix)]

ARGH! Bad Guitar!

Ouch! That's one hell of lot of distortion u got there!

Remove taht distortion! Please! cos otherwise, the piano and instrumetns in the melodies was great.

Intro wasn't too bad but outro was a bit too abrupt.

I particularly liked the second part as its heavy and the guitar soounds good there, unlike in the first part.

Overall, its not bad. But it deserves nothing more then a 7.

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

[Whales [Box-Killa]]

Strange...

It was a wierd tune, to be sure. Very ambientish and airy fairy if u get my drift. Of course the bass taht comes in definetely makes it better as do the drums, although these weren't particularly varied and got ur score down a bit,

Well, i seem to get a picture of seagulls flying over a moonlight sea not whales when i hear this, but that's just a matter of opinion.

OVerall, its a well thought out piece. keep up the good work!

Darklight17
=Review Request Club=

Box-Killa responds:

lol a 7! what is this! I guess it's just not your thing lol :D Thanks for the review! It varies plenty in my opinion! Its not a drum and bass song!